
McThrows: In previous conversations, we’ve generally focused on your experience working with elite athletes like Joe Kovacs, Ryan Crouser, and Kara Winger. But you mentioned that you’ve been thinking a lot lately about the best ways to train younger athletes. What got you ruminating on that topic?
JM: My oldest daughter is in eighth grade now, and she loves sports. She doesn’t want to be a weight lifter, but I knew at some point she’d be involved in weight training with one of her teams, so I wanted to make sure she could do the lifting movements safely and correctly, sort of bomb-proof her for the future.
As I’ve been working with my daughter, I’ve noticed some things that I think pertain to training young athletes in general.
For example, she has gotten pretty good at the Olympic movements. She can clean 40k pretty easily for 3×5. But, as soon as we put 45k on the bar, everything falls apart. Obviously, when you can do 40k for 3×5, you’re strong enough to handle 45k, but from a neural and coordination standpoint, she’s just not ready. And this tells me in her case, and it’s probably true for a lot of athletes around her age, the intensity of training—in terms of percentage of maximum—is not as important as working on coordination.
McThrows: How can you tell when a young athlete is ready for more intense weight training?
JM: It’s mostly an eye thing. For complex movements especially, the focus should be on doing it correctly and letting that dictate the load. I like the approach used by Jim Wendler, who wrote the book 5/3/1. He’s a powerlifting guy who does a lot of coaching with high school kids, and his philosophy is he wants all reps to be “awesome.” That requires patience. For example, if you start by teaching a young athlete to do jump shrugs with a PVC and after a few sessions you see they’re doing it pretty well, the next step is doing the same movement with an unloaded barbell. A few more sessions and then maybe you graduate them to doing muscle cleans, again with a minimal load, maybe just enough so they can feel the movement and how to receive the bar.
McThrows: Is there any reason to have a young athlete perform a single-rep max?
JM: First of all, the athlete should be training the movement often enough and long enough to get consistent at it before you think about trying heavy singles. Once their form is solid and consistent, it’s okay every now and then if a kid is feeling good to go ahead and try something.
But it’s good to keep in mind that
maxing out is a skill, and it may or may not
be in the athlete’s interest to put a lot
of emphasis on it.
Olympic lifters, obviously, spend a lot of time training singles because that’s the most important skill for an athlete in their sport. But if we’re doing sports performance training for track and field, soccer, or whatever, hitting heavy singles is not a skill we care about. At the Training Center, I used to tell our discus throwers, “Listen, we can get your power clean up, but throwing the discus far is what’s going to keep you in this program, so let’s keep the focus on that.”
That doesn’t mean we never did singles or tested for a max, but whatever we did was meant to serve the larger purpose of throwing the discus farther. For young athletes, we should be setting them up to stay healthy and have the best experience possible for as long as they’re in sports. Performing heavy singles is probably not a vital part of that.
McThrows: Your talk of caution and patience makes sense, but I remember when I was in high school and my friends and I went to see the movie “Pumping Iron.” All we wanted to do after that was kill ourselves in the weight room. How do you balance that passion—and yes, impatience—with the sensible approach you’ve described? I’m not sure we’d have shown up for a movie called “Pumping PVC.”
JM: For sure it’s fun to work hard and test yourself in the weight room, and it’s important to do that, but you have to pick the right movements where a kid can push it without taking needless risks.
If an athlete can’t perform sets of solid,
balanced reps with a light load in back squats for example, you shouldn’t be in a hurry to increase the weight.
But while you’re focusing on technique in back squats, there are plenty of simpler exercises a kid can do where they can start to explore their limits. Maybe you teach them step-ups or lunges just using body weight. Have them do 50 reps, however many sets it takes to get there. After a while you can have them hold dumbbells or step up to a higher box. For the upper body, you can do the same thing with dips and pushups. Then, once their technique is stable in more complex lifts, you can push harder in those as well.
Even then, though, it’s best not to include compound movements if the purpose of a given session is conditioning or developing toughness. I know circuit training is sometimes used with the idea of teaching the athletes to dig deep and keep pushing when they’re tired, but any movement that requires coordination also requires rest between sets. That’s true even if you are using a light load and focusing on developing a particular skill, such as the timing of your feet and hands when receiving a power clean. That’s not the time to take an athlete to failure. It would be better to have the athletes do one main lift first with proper recovery time and afterwards put them on the clock with a circuit of assistance-type exercises.
Like anything, it’s a balance.
Back in the day at Waubonsie Valley High School, we had a strength coach named Mark Arthur who I thought did a great job of making lifting fun without going overboard with the crazy stuff. It was the ‘90’s, and we mostly did the Husker Power strength program, but Coach Arthur knew we loved reading Flex Magazine, so he also let us do our biceps curls. And on Saturdays after we won a Friday night football game, we’d do some kind of fun challenge like who can hold a 45lb plate out in front of them the longest. He’d always have a challenge like that on his birthday as well, where he’d give out “Coach Arthur Birthday Challenge” t-shirts as prizes. We loved that stuff.
Looking back, I love the culture Coach Arthur created. He taught us to take it seriously and do the movements well, but he also made it a lot of fun.
Discover more from McThrows.com
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.